đ Divorce doesn't just end a marriage â it can shatter a man's entire identity.
In this powerful episode of the Don't Pick the Scab Podcast, host David sits down with Dr. Michael Ballard, a licensed psychologist with 20+ years of experience helping men in crisis at Ridgeline Counseling. Dr. Ballard is the author of Take Control of Your Anger, creator of The Good Husband Project, and his TEDx talk "Why Is It So Hard to Apologize?" has surpassed half a million views. đïž
After watching over 3,000 men try to rebuild their lives after blowing up their marriages, Dr. Ballard knows the patterns that keep men stuck â and exactly how to break free. đ
In this episode, we cover:
đ§ Why anger is never the real emotion â Dr. Ballard reveals what anger is actually covering up: fear, shame, embarrassment, and the terror of an unplanned future.
đ€ The shame spiral â Why men beat themselves up after divorce, and how to take accountability WITHOUT self-flagellation. (Hint: think like a quarterback who threw an interception. đ)
đ The art of the real apology â Why "I'm sorry you feel that way" isn't an apology, why you can't rush someone through forgiveness, and why you may need to apologize to YOURSELF.
đŒ Why career success won't save you â You can crush it at work and still be falling apart at home. Research shows problems in your closest relationships impact you more than anything else.
đ© Narcissists, gaslighting & labels â Why slapping a diagnostic label on your ex feels good but keeps YOU stuck.
đšâđ§ High-conflict co-parenting â The #1 rule Dr. Ballard teaches men: DON'T HIT SEND. âïž Plus, why you can't control what happens at your ex's house (and what you CAN control behind your own front door).
đ The Jack-in-the-Box dad â Why staying stuck in the box is destroying you AND your kids.
đȘ "You're not too far gone" â A straight-up message of hope for the 50-year-old man who thinks he's too broken, too old, or too late. Rebuild your life brick by brick. đ§±
Whether you're in the thick of divorce, recovering from one, or trying to save your marriage â this conversation will challenge you, comfort you, and give you a roadmap forward.
đ© Find Dr. Michael Ballard at www.MichaelBallard.net and follow The Good Husband Project on Substack.
đ If this episode hit home, smash that LIKE button, SUBSCRIBE for new episodes every week, and hit the đ so you never miss an upload.
đŹ JOIN THE CONVERSATION: What's the ONE emotion your anger has been covering up? Drop it in the comments below â your story might be exactly what another brother needs to hear today. đ
#DivorceRecovery #MenOver40 #DontPickTheScabPodcast #MensMentalHealth #AngerManagement #CoParenting #LifeAfterDivorce
Hosted on Ausha. See ausha.co/privacy-policy for more information.
[00:00:00] Welcome back everyone. Today's guest is the man who spent more than two decades sitting across from men at their lowest moments and showing them the way back. Dr. Michael Ballard is a licensed psychologist at Ridgeline Counseling with 20 plus years of experience working with men in crisis. He's the author of Take Control of Your Anger and his TEDx talk, Why Is It So Hard to Apologize? It has passed half a million views because let's be honest, fellas, apologizing is hard.
[00:00:30] His upcoming book, The Good Husband Project, is born from watching over 3,000 men try to rebuild after blowing up their marriages. In some of those lessons, he learned the hard way in his own life. He works in the exact territory our listeners are navigating. The shame spiraled, the identity collapsed, the anger covering what a man doesn't yet have words for. Please welcome Michael Ballard. Thanks for coming to the show. Michael, tell us about yourself and we've got some questions for you.
[00:00:58] Michael Ballard. Thanks. I'm so glad to be here. I just love being able to talk to men and couples, women as well, who have been dealing with all kinds of problems and struggles in their lives. A lot of times men come in my office during a divorce, leading up to a divorce, right after a divorce, trying to rebuild their lives afterwards. And it's really rewarding to help them through that path. How can we men accept therapy more?
[00:01:25] Man, that's the question.
[00:01:29] It's a big one because I think a lot of men fight it. We don't want to be in therapy. We feel like we don't need it. Therapies for people who are weak or who have big problems. My problem is not big enough for therapy. And I think just acknowledging we all make mistakes. We all struggle. We all have a hard time. We're all dealing with stuff. That's not that big of a deal. Let's just say, hey, I'm in a tough spot right now. I can talk to somebody who can help me out.
[00:01:58] You've watched over 3,000 men try to rebuild after blowing up their marriages. What patterns show up again and again? What similar patterns keep showing up?
[00:02:39] So you said anger is usually covering something a man doesn't have words for yet. What is it actually hiding underneath, you think? There's a couple possibilities. Sometimes it's fear. What's life going to look like for me now? I thought I had a map of the way things were going to go. I thought I had everything all planned out and I knew my future. Now I don't. And I'm scared of the question marks that are ahead of me.
[00:03:05] Sometimes it's embarrassment and judgment from others. They don't want to feel looked at, looked down upon. And sometimes it's shame. It's this feeling that not just that I did something bad, but I am someone bad. And those are hard feelings to sit with. They can roll into sadness and depression. It's hard to sit in that. So a lot of times anger covers those feelings.
[00:03:30] And it can be easier to feel angry than it is to sit in sadness or sit in shame and sit in those places. So it's all anger bad or is there a healthy version man should learn to use? Oh, anger is not bad in and of itself. Anger can be very healthy because it can help us to see what's wrong, right? It can be something to show us kind of like a warning light on the dashboard. There's something that's off here. There's something that's not right. And it can motivate you to act in a good way.
[00:03:59] I tell people all the time, anger is not the problem. It's what you do with it's the problem. If somebody treats your kid poorly and you get angry about it, that's fine. If you go to the school, have a tough conversation. No problem. Good. If you go slash their tires in the parking lot, that's a different situation. So you're talking about accountability without self-flagellation. What is self-flagellation?
[00:04:24] It's when you just beat yourself up. You look at yourself and you say, I made this mistake and I've ruined everything and it's all my fault and I'm never going to be able to rebuild anything. And the things that I've done can't be undone. And I've lost my marriage and I've lost sometimes my financial state. And I've lost my relationship with my kids and it's all falled apart and it will never, ever come back.
[00:04:52] And so many men get caught up in that of just beating themselves up over and over. So how does a man take real responsibility for his part in the marriage without ending in or drowning in guilt? I think there's a really important skill here that frankly, most men don't have.
[00:05:13] That's when you look at what you did, take ownership and accountability with what you did without beating yourself up at too much. It's this line you got to say. If you say, I didn't do anything wrong. I'm perfect. Or it was all her fault. That's no good because there's no accountability. If you say, it's all my fault. I'm a failure. I'm a loser. No one will ever love me. That's no good. We swung too far on the other side. So it's this line. I say to guys sometimes, you see a quarterback throw an interception.
[00:05:43] You don't want him to go back to the bench and say, I'm an idiot. I'm a loser. I'm never going to do this. That's not going to help. He's not going to do better after that. But you also don't want him to say, oh, no problem. That wasn't my fault. That was my receiver's fault. No, you just want him to say, I made a mistake. Let me look at my mistake. Let me learn from that mistake and then let me move on. Don't get stuck in it. Don't get mired down in all of that. So half a million people have watched your TEDx talk. So why is it hard to apologize?
[00:06:12] And what's the relationship of apologizing and forgiveness? Oh, it's a big one. I think you can forgive without an apology. And sometimes you'll never get an apology. And you still can work through forgiveness on that. But apology can open the door for forgiveness.
[00:06:33] And so often there's resentment and there's bitterness that just being able to say, hey, I'm sorry can go a long way. Growing up, my parents got divorced. And for more than 30 years, my mom would say he still hasn't said he's sorry. He still hasn't apologized. My dad had moved on. He'd remarried. He had a whole new life.
[00:06:59] And she was holding on, waiting for that apology. For so many people, it's hard. It is hard to say you're sorry. It's hard to admit you're wrong. You're afraid of what the consequences might be. Maybe there's pride involved in it. Maybe there's shame. Because if I admit to you I did something wrong, maybe it means I'm a lesser person in my eyes. And so all this just gets in the way of our healing and of moving on. Yeah.
[00:07:29] Wow. So what separates an apology that actually repairs from one that makes things worse? A lot of times when people apologize, they do make things worse. And sometimes they'll say things like, I'm sorry you feel that way. And you're like, that's not an apology. You didn't apologize. But it feels so good. It feels so good. Oh, I'm sorry if you think that's a problem. And you go, no.
[00:07:59] No, that's one of those celebrities when they stand up and make a public apology. And you're like, you're not actually apologizing. I'm sorry if anyone in here interpreted my remarks this way. And you're like, stop it. That's not helping. Or the other thing I see a lot of times is, I'm sorry. Now, can't we just move on and get back to whatever's going on? Let's move through it quickly. I'm just saying I'm sorry so we can finish this conversation and move on. And I'm sorry. Do you forgive me? Can we get back to being good?
[00:08:29] And the person's like, hold on. Don't rush me through this. And that can make it worse. Wow. What about apologizing to yourself? How important is that? It's a big deal because we all make mistakes. The best of us make mistakes every day. And being able to look at it and saying, okay, I missed that one. That was a dumb move. But again, don't beat yourself up. Not, I'm an idiot. I'm a loser.
[00:08:59] I'm a failure. No, no. That was just a mistake. I made that mistake. Let me understand why. Let me understand what happened so I can learn from it. And then let me acknowledge, okay, all right. You didn't show up today the way you should have. Let's learn from that. I'm sorry I didn't do what I should have done. Let's take inventory of that. Let's fix it and move on. And don't get stuck in it. Don't get stuck in this hole of just beating yourself up.
[00:09:26] I say a lot of times the secret to this is you own it, you fix it, and you move on. And that's it. But not in a hurry, though. Not in a hurry. And you can't rush the person. Because sometimes you say, all right, I'm sorry. Can we get over it? And the person's like, I'm not there yet. I need a little bit more time to process this and work through it. And it's not okay for you to say, I said I'm sorry, so we're moving on. That's all it means. That's it. Yeah. It's not going to work.
[00:09:55] So you talk about the moment where being good at everything else means nothing if your marriage is in pieces. Why doesn't career success insulate a man from this collapse? You can. You can be really successful in your career. You can do extremely well. And a lot of men do. At the same time, if there's problems at home, if there's problems in your relationships, you can hide them.
[00:10:21] And I talk to men who work extra hours trying to distract themselves from whatever's going on at home so they don't feel the pain, so they don't struggle with that. It's still there. And it eats away at you. Research shows us this. Problems in your closest relationships impact you more than anything else. Wow. If you have a bad day at the job, it's not the same as having a bad day at home with your closest people and your closest relationships. And you can't just fix it by focusing over here and ignoring over there.
[00:10:51] So what happens to a man's identity when the husband's role suddenly disappears? Oof. It's a huge one. Because it's part of who you are. And so all of a sudden, you're not the same person as you thought you were before. And you don't see yourself in the same way. You can still be a dad. You can still be an employee. You can still be a friend. You can still be a son. But when you're not a husband, you have to adjust to that.
[00:11:20] And for a lot of men, that's a feeling of failure. It's a feeling of weakness. It's a feeling of shame. That I'm no longer this title that I've had for myself. And there has to be some grief around that. Of acknowledging, okay, I may not be a husband and let's own that. It doesn't change who I am as a person. It doesn't mean I'm deficient as a man. Okay.
[00:11:48] Does the term I failed at marriage, is it really true? Or do you try to say something else instead? I think it's hard to say I failed at marriage because there's so many variables. It's not like you were taking a math test and you failed the math test. And you were the only one taking the test, right? It's a relationship. And a relationship has factors of two people that are going on. And there's so many different variables.
[00:12:17] You can't just say I failed. I think you can be a very good husband and still end up in a divorce. And that doesn't mean that you failed in marriage. Yeah. What about the self-cousins, self-respect, self, all those self-cousins? They all play a part with identity. How does that work? I think a big part is how you see yourself.
[00:12:43] And in our world today, a lot of people base their identity on how others see them. I had a guy this week say, I'm not feeling good about myself because women aren't saying yes to me when I ask them out. And since I'm not having success with them, I don't feel good about me. Right? Come on, man. Interesting.
[00:13:08] And you go, you can't give yourself identity, your self-respect, your self-esteem. You can't give a random woman the keys to that and say, this person that I met at a bar, she said no to me. Therefore, I'm not a worthy human being. You go, hold on a second. No, no, no. That's not the way it is. You have to be able to see who you are.
[00:13:34] And it's not judged by someone else's evaluation, especially somebody you just met who doesn't even know you. Yeah. God, no kidding. Tell us about the Good Husband Project. What's the core message? And who is it for? The man trying to save his marriage or the man who's already lost it? I think the Good Husband Project is something I'm really excited about. It's a book I've written. It's at the editors. They're working on it. And it's a sub-stack newsletter that I have coming out every week.
[00:14:03] Sometimes it's men who are in a marriage and they want it to be better. Sometimes it's men whose marriage are really struggling and they want it to turn around. And sometimes it's men who say, okay, I have a divorce and I'm restarting and I want to get it right this time. And I want to make sure this time I don't make the same mistakes I made last time. And I want to do my part in being a good husband to show up in that way. Okay.
[00:14:31] So what does a good husband actually look like in practice? It's a great question. A lot of times we think about what a good husband does and we say, oh, a good husband supports his wife and takes care of the kids and has a good job and helps around the house. Because I actually think that's the wrong way to look at it. Because there's a lot of men who can do those things and check the boxes, but don't have the right character underneath it.
[00:14:58] Because I can buy you flowers and be manipulative about it. I can clean up the house and hold a grudge against you for doing it. What it really is having the character of a solid man who shows up and does the right thing, not just in your actions, but who you are. Let's talk about the buzzwords that we talked about earlier in the pre-interview.
[00:15:26] Narcissism, gaslighting, and alienation. How do those show up in your practice? All the time. They're everywhere. I guess the first way to say it is they are buzzwords in our culture, which as a psychologist, frankly, is a little annoying. People come in my office and they say, oh, I realize that my wife is a narcissist because I saw something on Instagram.
[00:15:55] And you go, okay. You don't walk into a hospital and say, I realized I had a heart attack because I saw something on Instagram. There's actually looks and criteria. No, I saw a 30-second video and it sounded just like hers. Yeah, exactly. And you go, oh, man. Now, I think it's helpful to be aware of some of the patterns. It's not helpful when we slap labels on everything and we say, it's not my fault because my ex was
[00:16:24] a borderline and she was crazy. And so, therefore, it's a simple story, right? Yeah. It's all her fault. Well, she's got a label. Therefore, I'm good. I did nothing wrong. And I go, come on. Relationships are not that simple. We shouldn't go blame somebody and throw a diagnostic label at them. We have to be able to look at ourselves, too. But it feels so good when you throw that label. It does. It feels good. It feels good.
[00:16:53] And it's a lot of it feels good, but it's not really good for you. Yeah. Certainly not good for you in the long run. Yeah. So is genuine change possible for a man who spent decades in the same patterns? Or what does it actually take? You can. It takes consistent work and consistent effort. And what I'll tell you is, for instance, the thing coming to my office all the time right now is people pleasing.
[00:17:20] And I will meet with men who have been over accommodating, people pleasing, bending over backwards for their wives for 20 years. And then they say to me, I think I need to change that. Now, can they change it? Yes. But it's not easy.
[00:17:37] If you've been doing anything every day for 20 years to unlearn that, it's kind of when a dog has a really bad habit and you try to untrain them, it's harder to untrain them than it is to learn a new habit. And we're the same way. We all are the same way. We're okay. Can we learn? Can we consistently create new change? Yes. But you've got to do it every day. And you've got to be conscious and deliberate.
[00:18:05] And you usually have to have a guide to help you along the way. Because if you've done something the same way over and over again, you're going to keep doing it that way. Yeah. For the guys who've never set foot in a therapist's office, demystify it for them. I guess what I would tell you is therapy can be as simple as sitting down and talking to somebody about what's going on in your life. And I had a guy this week who said, never once have I sat in a therapist's office. And I said, what do you think?
[00:18:34] He said, I'm a little scared. Coming in here right away. I don't know what you're going to do. If you're going to talk to me about my childhood and my mother and we're going to look at inkblots. And I said, we're not going to do any of those things. I just said, what's going on in your life? And at the end of the hour, he was like, hey, this was actually pretty good. And I'm like, good, good. I'm glad. I'm not shocking you with any electrical things. I'm not digging through.
[00:18:58] We're just talking about what's going on in your life and what's in your situation from a guy who's been there to say, all right, how do we make different choices to get to a different place? Yeah, you got to quit seeing those guys from TikTok. Yes, that's not the answer. What's a few beliefs about men and emotional recovery that you spend your career pushing back against?
[00:19:25] I think the idea that a lot of people believe men have no feelings is just not true. Men don't feel they're just purely logical. Men have lots of feelings. We may not understand them all the time and we may not have the same vocabulary for them.
[00:19:46] I say sometimes when my wife wants to paint the house, she'll ask me 42 different shades of white and I look at them and I go, they're all white. I don't know what I have no vocabulary here to know what to do. Sometimes with our feelings, it's the same where I just say I feel sad and we have to learn. Okay, is that a disappointment? Is that a feeling of rejection? Is that a feeling of loneliness? Is it actually a feeling of worry?
[00:20:14] We have to learn and grow in that. The idea that we don't feel though, it's not true. Maybe we cover it up and maybe we're not as aware, but we do. The feelings are there. Yeah. Let's switch gears to co-parenting. So there's a lot of high conflict co-parenting situations out there. What are some of the things you tell the men that are in a high conflict co-parenting space, some of the things they can do?
[00:20:41] There's a lot of important things here and sadly it's way too common in our world. I think one of the most important things is to be really careful about what you say and to be really careful about what you write. I say almost on a daily basis, don't hit send, right? If you're really mad and you're putting that email in, you're putting your text message, maybe you're on an app like Talking Parents. Yeah. Be careful because you get upset, you get angry, you fire something off.
[00:21:10] And I will tell you, I have been in a courtroom where they stand up and it's like a TV show. They've blown this up and they're like, is this text message yours? And it's just everybody in the courtroom cringes. And they say, yeah, yeah, did you write this? Oh, your honor, does this sound like a guy who should be around children? And everybody just goes, oh no. I get it. We all have those thoughts. Don't hit send.
[00:21:37] Be careful when you do that because it can go so badly for you. You know, one of my big things is there was a small K and a big K. And there was a K with exclamation marks. So I had three just K. After a big long thing from her, K. Yeah. Because it just de-escalated everything. But yeah. What do you say to the 50-year-old man listening right now who's convinced that he's too broken, too old or too far gone?
[00:22:08] I will say that I have seen you in my office many times and there is hope and things can change. You are not too far gone. There is a way to rebuild your life brick by brick. It's going to take some work. It's going to take some effort. And at the same time, what you're living in right now is hard anyway.
[00:22:31] So if you have to pick your hard, I'm picking a hard that's going to rebuild and get better as opposed to picking a hard where I just stay stuck in the place where I am. It can get better. You can change and make things better. You just got to take the steps and get there. And what about the men out there? We talked about this earlier, too, who have a hard time letting go of trying to control what happens at the ex's house? Oh, that's a hard one.
[00:22:59] The truth is you have control over your home. You have control what happens behind your front door and you don't have control over hers. And I work with men who every little thing of she's feeding them pizza and I don't appreciate that. And she can't feed them pizza. And you go, I'm sorry. I'm sorry, man. You can't tell her what she can feed and what she can't. She showed them this movie.
[00:23:29] She did. You can't. And I promise you through the court of law, unless we're talking about serious abuse that's going on, you try to go to court and say, oh, this is no good because she's doing this and she's it's not going anywhere. And so you have to accept. All right. When they're with me, I've got the rules. I've got the consequences. I've got the structure. I can have bedtimes. I can have routines at my house.
[00:23:56] And if they go over there and they don't have routines and they don't have bedtimes and they don't brush their teeth and whatever's going on, I can't control that. And I have to accept that's a reality of my life. Yeah. So you've heard about the Jack in the Box dad, right? Yes. Yeah. Talk to me about the Jack in the Box dad. Talk to him out there. Tell him to get out of the box. I think so often you feel stuck.
[00:24:22] You feel stuck in this box and you feel like there's no way out. And I will tell you, it's not going to work. It's not your path for you. You are putting yourself in a situation that's going to make your life worse and going to make your kid's life worse. And you got to get out. You got to do something different and you can't stay there. It's not possible. Yeah. Plus, you're probably going to suffocate. Yeah. You are. Nobody needs that.
[00:24:52] No. All right, Doc. My men have about a half hour attention span. Where can they find you on the internet? You can find me at michaelballard.net or the Good Husband Project substack. Okay. And one outgoing piece of advice, please. I would say divorce is hard. Rebuilding from divorce is hard. But you can do it. I see men do it. It's possible.
[00:25:19] And you can actually build a beautiful, wonderful life for yourself. It may not seem possible right now. You may be in a very dark place. I've seen it. You can do it. It's possible. Rebuild that life brick by brick, day by day. You can get there. All right, Doc. We appreciate your time. And that was awesome. That was very interesting. You made me think about quite a few things. But we appreciate you taking time to hang out with us.
[00:25:49] Oh, you're very welcome. It was great to be here. And don't go anywhere. Thank you.

